Pumpkin Pet Insurance Review 2026

Pumpkin pet insurance review: a young woman sitting on a sunlit living room floor

By the Real Pet Cost editorial team · Prices reviewed October 2026 · How we estimate costs

Quick answerOur Pumpkin pet insurance review in short: Pumpkin offers one accident and illness plan with 80% or 90% reimbursement, $100–$1,000 deductibles and annual limits up to unlimited. Exam fees, dental illness and behavioral care are included, and a 14-day wait applies in most states even to hip and knee problems. Preventive Essentials stopped selling on August 18, 2026.
80–90%Reimbursement options
14 daysWaiting period, incl. hips and knees (most states)
$5K–unlimitedAnnual limit options

Pumpkin has sold pet insurance in the US since 2020. It offers one accident and illness plan for dogs and cats, with exam fees, dental illness and behavioral care built in and the same 14-day wait for most conditions, including hip and knee problems. Its preventive side changed in 2026, so older reviews may describe an add-on you can no longer buy.

Below: who actually insures your pet, the coverage details, reported prices, how claims are paid and how Pumpkin compares.

Pumpkin Pet Insurance at a Glance

FeaturePumpkin
Insurer (underwriter)Independence American Insurance Company or United States Fire Insurance Company, depending on the policy
Agency / administratorPumpkin Insurance Services Inc., a licensed agency (not the insurer)
Plan typeOne accident & illness plan; no accident-only plan
Reimbursement80% or 90%, with 90% open to pets of any age from 8 weeks
Annual deductible$100, $250, $500 or $1,000 (per NerdWallet)
Annual limitDogs: $5,000, $10,000, $20,000 or unlimited. Cats: $5,000, $7,000, $15,000 or unlimited
Waiting periods14 days in most states for accidents and illnesses, including hip dysplasia and knee injuries
Enrollment age8 weeks and up; no upper age limit
Exam feesIncluded for accident and illness visits, in-office or virtual
Dental / behavioralDental illness and behavioral issues included
WellnessPumpkin Wellness Club (not insurance); Preventive Essentials closed to new buyers on August 18, 2026
WhereAll 50 states and D.C. (per NerdWallet); any licensed vet in the US or Canada

Figures come from Pumpkin’s homepage, FAQ, claims and comparison pages (checked October 2026), cross-checked with NerdWallet (May 2026) and Insurify (May 2026). Pumpkin’s own pages don’t list deductible amounts, so those come from NerdWallet and Insurify. Coverage is subject to each policy’s terms, exclusions and state availability.

Who’s behind Pumpkin

Pumpkin is a licensed insurance agency, not an insurance company. Policies are underwritten by either Independence American Insurance Company (Scottsdale, Arizona) or United States Fire Insurance Company (Morristown, New Jersey); your policy forms name which one applies. Pumpkin’s wellness memberships are run separately by Sprout Wellness Services LLC, a Pumpkin subsidiary.

How Much Does Pumpkin Pet Insurance Cost?

Pumpkin doesn’t publish a national average premium, so the figures below come from independent sample quotes:

Source (date)What it reports
NerdWallet sample quotes (May 2026, Katy, TX, $250 deductible, $5,000 limit, 80%)Labrador $45 at age 2, $112 at age 8; medium mixed breed $32 and $80; French Bulldog $64 and $158
NerdWallet sample quotes, cats (same limit)Domestic shorthair $15 at age 2, $28 at age 8; Maine Coon $23 and $43
Insurify quote data (May 2026)Median about $78/month for dogs and $32 for cats; dog quotes $43–$148, cat quotes $20–$82
ConsumerAffairs examples (August 2026)8-week-old puppy in California $32–$101/month; 4-year-old cat in Arizona $19–$77/month

Insurify’s median is higher than NerdWallet’s samples because it mixes all ages, limits and deductibles, including unlimited plans. For context, NAPHIA’s US averages for accident and illness coverage are about $62 a month for dogs and $32 for cats. Our pet insurance cost guide explains how age, breed, ZIP code and deductible move a quote.

What moves a Pumpkin quote

Pumpkin says premiums depend on your pet’s age, species or breed and your home address. Within a quote, the levers you control are:

  • Deductible: moving from $100 toward $1,000 lowers the monthly price but raises what you pay before coverage starts each year
  • Reimbursement: 80% costs less than 90%
  • Annual limit: a $5,000 or $10,000 limit costs less than unlimited, but a single surgery plus follow-up can reach that cap
  • Timing: enrolling while your pet is young and healthy avoids both higher age pricing and pre-existing exclusions

Discounts

  • Multi-pet: 10% off each additional pet, per Pumpkin
  • Veterinary staff: savings reported by NerdWallet
  • Annual payment: NerdWallet notes possible savings for paying yearly

What’s Covered and Not Covered

Included in the plan

Pumpkin’s plan covers accidents and illnesses, including hereditary conditions, cancer, infections and parasites. Pumpkin lists these as part of the standard plan with no add-on fee:

  • Exam fees for accident and illness visits, in person or virtual
  • Dental illness such as gum disease, with no annual dental exam required
  • Behavioral issues: diagnostics, therapy and prescription medications
  • Alternative and physical therapy for covered conditions
  • Prescription food and supplements for covered conditions
  • Diagnostics, surgery, hospitalization and medications

Not covered

  • Pre-existing conditions; curable ones may be covered if symptom- and treatment-free for 180 days, except knee and hind-leg ligament conditions
  • Vaccines and routine care
  • Routine dental cleanings, including cleanings to treat periodontal disease
  • Breeding, pregnancy, cosmetic procedures and herbal supplements (per NerdWallet)
Good to know: Pumpkin’s 14-day wait covers hip dysplasia and cruciate ligament injuries too. Some insurers use 6 or 12 months for these, which matters for large, active dogs.

Pumpkin Preventive Essentials and Wellness Club

Many searches still ask about Pumpkin Preventive Essentials. It was an optional add-on, sold only with a Pumpkin policy, that refunded a yearly wellness exam, a set number of vaccines and parasite screening. Pumpkin’s FAQ states that as of August 18, 2026, Preventive Essentials is no longer available for purchase. Pets enrolled before that date keep the terms in their customer agreement, which owners can view in their online account. It was never insurance and was not sold in CA, ME, MO, MT, RI, VT or WA.

Pumpkin now points owners to the Pumpkin Wellness Club, a membership launched in September 2024 that can be bought with or without insurance:

DetailPumpkin Wellness Club
TiersEssential, Premium and Elite, for dogs and cats
Starting price (2026)Dogs from $20.95/month; cats from $15.95/month
What it paysCash back up to set amounts for exams, vaccines, fecal and blood tests; higher tiers add parasite prevention, spay/neuter or dental cleaning, and grooming (Elite)
Term12 months; leaving early can mean fees owed
StatusNot insurance; administered by Sprout Wellness Services LLC

Pumpkin says members can save up to $515 a year. Whether a membership pays off depends on what your pet’s routine care costs where you live; our pet wellness plan cost guide lists typical prices to compare against.

Pros and Cons

Pumpkin pet insurance review: an older man on a backyard porch step stroking a gray-muzzled German shepherd mix lying at his

Pros

  • Exam fees, dental illness and behavioral care included without add-ons
  • 14-day wait in most states, even for hip and knee problems
  • No upper enrollment age, and the 90% option is open to seniors
  • Annual limits up to unlimited, plus 10% off each additional pet
  • PumpkinNow can pay eligible bills of $500 or more before you check out
  • A+ BBB rating with 4.44 out of 5 stars from 317 reviews (October 2026)

Cons

  • No 70% option in most listings and no accident-only plan, so fewer ways to lower the premium
  • No published average premium; independent medians can run high for dogs
  • Preventive Essentials is closed to new buyers, and the Wellness Club is a separate 12-month commitment
  • Herbal supplements and routine cleanings excluded
  • NerdWallet lists the lack of a mobile app as a drawback

Pumpkin Customer Ratings and Reviews

Review scores for Pumpkin differ by platform and by date, so it helps to look at more than one:

Platform (date)Rating
BBB (checked October 2026)A+ rating, BBB accredited; 4.44 out of 5 stars from 317 customer reviews
NerdWallet editorial rating (May 2026)5.0 out of 5
Trustpilot, as reported by Insurify (May 2026)4.5 stars from 952 reviews
ConsumerAffairs (updated August 2026)Only 2 reviews, too few to be meaningful

Insurify’s May 2026 snapshot of Pumpkin’s BBB profile showed much lower figures than the profile did in October 2026, a reminder that these scores move. Check the live pages before you rely on any one number.

How Claims Work

  1. Visit any licensed vet in the US or Canada.
  2. Submit the claim form and itemized invoice in your member account. Pumpkin allows 270 days to file in states that permit a time limit.
  3. Pumpkin says eligible claims are typically paid “in a few days.” ConsumerAffairs reports most are processed within 10 to 14 days.
  4. Payment goes to your bank by direct deposit or by mailed check.

PumpkinNow

For a final vet invoice of $500 or more, you can ask Pumpkin to pay before you settle the bill. Pumpkin says eligible PumpkinNow claims can be paid in as little as 15 minutes with a bank that supports real-time payments, or in 2–3 days by direct deposit.

Payout formula

NerdWallet reports that Pumpkin subtracts the deductible first, then applies your reimbursement rate. On a $2,000 bill with a $250 deductible at 80%, that’s ($2,000 − $250) × 80% = $1,400. Insurers that apply the rate first would pay $1,350 on the same bill.

Reimbursement rate$2,000 bill, $250 deductibleExample payout
80%$1,750 × 80%$1,400
90%$1,750 × 90%$1,575

The 90% option raises the premium, so weigh the extra $175 per $2,000 claim against the higher monthly cost in your quote.

Who It May Suit / Who Might Look Elsewhere

Pumpkin may suit owners who:

  • Have a large or athletic dog and want a short orthopedic waiting period
  • Want exam fees, dental illness and behavioral care without choosing add-ons
  • Are enrolling a senior pet and want the 90% option
  • Have several pets and can use the 10% multi-pet discount

Owners might compare other options if they:

  • Want a cheaper accident-only plan or a 70% reimbursement option
  • Mainly want routine care covered inside the insurance policy
  • Prefer managing claims in a dedicated app
  • Want herbal or holistic supplements covered

Things to Check Before You Enroll

  • Your underwriter. Your policy forms show whether Independence American or US Fire insures you.
  • Your state’s waiting period. The 14-day figure applies in most states; check your declarations page.
  • Cancellation window. In most states you get a full refund within 30 days if no claim was filed (15 days in LA, ME, MT and WA).
  • Wellness math. Add up a year of exams, vaccines and tests and compare it with 12 months of Wellness Club fees.
  • Records for curable conditions. Keep proof of the 180 symptom-free days if your pet had a past illness.

Could pet insurance cover a bill like this?

Accident & illness plans typically reimburse 70–90% of eligible vet costs after the deductible, if the condition is not pre-existing and the waiting period has passed. Premiums for dogs average about $62/month and for cats about $32/month (NAPHIA, 2025).

See if pet insurance is worth it →

Coverage is subject to each policy’s terms, exclusions and state availability.

How It Compares

InsurerReimbursementAnnual limitsExam feesUpper age limit
Pumpkin80–90%$5,000–unlimitedIncludedNone
Fetch70–90%$5,000–$15,000 (unlimited by phone)IncludedNone
Lemonade70–90%$5,000–$100,000Add-onVaries by breed
Embrace70–90%Several, up to unlimitedAdd-onFull coverage under 15

See our Lemonade review for a modular, add-on approach to compare against.

Real Vet Bills It Could Help With

Typical US costs from our price guides, with an illustrative Pumpkin payout at 80% reimbursement and a $250 deductible, using the deductible-first method reported by NerdWallet: (bill − $250) × 80%. It assumes the condition is covered, not pre-existing, past the waiting period and that the deductible hasn’t been met yet that year.

TreatmentTypical costExample payout
Emergency vet visit (no surgery)About $950About $560
Parvo hospitalization (general vet)About $2,500About $1,800
Dog intestinal blockage surgeryAbout $4,000About $3,000
Dog ACL surgery (TPLO)About $4,500 per kneeAbout $3,400

These are simple illustrations, not quotes. Once the deductible is met, later claims that year pay 80% of covered costs. Excluded items and your annual limit can lower the real amount.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much does Pumpkin pet insurance cost?

Pumpkin doesn’t publish a national average. NerdWallet’s May 2026 sample quotes ranged from about $32 to $64 a month for 2-year-old dogs and $15 to $28 for 2-year-old cats, while Insurify’s quote data put the median near $78 for dogs and $32 for cats. Age, breed, location, deductible and limit drive the price.

Is Pumpkin Preventive Essentials still available?

No. Pumpkin’s FAQ says that as of August 18, 2026, Preventive Essentials is no longer available for purchase. Pets enrolled before then keep the terms in their customer agreement. Pumpkin now offers the Pumpkin Wellness Club, a membership that is not insurance, from $20.95 a month for dogs and $15.95 for cats.

Who underwrites Pumpkin pet insurance?

Pumpkin Insurance Services Inc. is a licensed agency, not the insurer. Policies are underwritten by either Independence American Insurance Company or United States Fire Insurance Company, and your policy forms name which one applies.

What is Pumpkin's waiting period?

In most states, coverage for accidents and illnesses starts 14 days after the policy effective date. That includes hip dysplasia and cruciate ligament injuries, which some insurers make wait 6 to 12 months.

How fast does Pumpkin pay claims?

Pumpkin says eligible claims are typically paid in a few days, while ConsumerAffairs reports most are processed within 10 to 14 days. With PumpkinNow, eligible bills of $500 or more can be paid before checkout, in as little as 15 minutes with a real-time-payment bank.

Sources and methodology. Prices are national ranges compiled from the sources below and cross-checked in October 2026. Local prices vary with the clinic, your pet’s size and health, and your region.

Not veterinary advice. Prices are estimates for budgeting, not quotes. Ask your veterinarian for a written, itemized estimate. If your pet is injured, in pain or acting unwell, contact your vet or an emergency animal hospital right away.